If a letter from your student loan servicer has been sitting unopened on the counter, you’re in good company, and you still have room to move. SAVE is over, and the choice of RAP vs IBR is yours to make, but only until the date printed on that letter.
What’s happening to SAVE, in plain terms
The U.S. Department of Education says a court ended the SAVE plan and that its roughly 7.5 million borrowers are being moved into other plans. Starting July 1, 2026, servicers began sending notices giving each borrower 90 days to pick a new plan. If you don’t pick, the Department places you in the Standard plan or the new Tiered Standard plan. Both are fixed payments that ignore what you earn.
There is no single national deadline. Your servicer tells you yours. Edfinancial, one of the federal loan servicers, says its notices went out between July 1 and August 15, with 90 days from the date on the notice. If you can’t find your letter, log into your servicer account; the deadline is on file there.
Two income-based options are on the table for most SAVE borrowers: RAP (the Repayment Assistance Plan, new as of July 2026) and IBR (Income-Based Repayment, the older plan that survived). The right one depends on numbers you already have.
The math on one real budget
Take one example, close to a lot of our readers: $45,000 in AGI (adjusted gross income, the line near the bottom of page 1 of your 1040), one kid, filing head of household, and $28,000 in unsubsidized federal loans at 5.5% interest. Your real rate is on your servicer account.
- If you do nothing (Standard, 10 years): about $304 a month. The interest alone is $28,000 × 5.5% ÷ 12 = $128 a month. Paying off the $28,000 plus that interest in 120 equal payments comes to $304. The Tiered Standard plan stretches the term based on your balance, so it can land lower, but it still doesn’t care what you earn.
- RAP: $100 a month. RAP takes a percentage of your AGI, set by income band. For AGI between $40,000 and $50,000, it’s 4%, per the Edfinancial RAP page. So $45,000 × 4% = $1,800 a year, or $150 a month. Then RAP subtracts $50 a month for each dependent on your tax return. One kid: $150 minus $50 = $100. The floor is $10 a month.
- IBR: about $105 or $157 a month. IBR charges 10% or 15% of your discretionary income, depending on when you took out your first loans (Edfinancial IBR page). Discretionary income is your AGI minus 150% of the federal poverty guideline for your family size. The 2026 guideline for a household of two is $21,640 (HHS, Federal Register), so 150% is $32,460. $45,000 minus $32,460 leaves $12,540. At 10%, that’s $1,254 a year, or $105 a month. At 15%, it’s $1,881 a year, or $157 a month. Your servicer can tell you which rate applies to you.
So against the Standard plan, RAP keeps about $204 a month in this budget. Over a year, that’s $2,448.
Why the monthly payment isn’t the whole story
On these loans, interest runs about $128 a month. Both plans charge less than that, and what happens to the leftover is where they split.
- Under RAP, when you make your full payment on time, the interest your payment doesn’t cover isn’t charged, and a principal subsidy makes sure your balance drops by at least $50 that month, according to the Massachusetts Attorney General. In this example, that’s $600 off the balance in the first year while paying $100 a month.
- Under IBR at $105, about $24 a month of interest goes unpaid. Over a year, that’s roughly $286 owed on top of the balance. IBR only covers unpaid interest on subsidized loans, and only for the first three years (Edfinancial IBR page). Unsubsidized loans get no help.
The finish line is different too. IBR forgives what’s left after 20 or 25 years. RAP takes 30 years (360 qualifying payments), per Edfinancial, which also notes that forgiven balances may count as taxable income.
Which one fits you
For a reader at this stage (one income under about $60,000, a kid or two, unsubsidized loans, no long history of income-driven payments), RAP usually wins on both counts: a lower bill now and a balance that actually goes down.
IBR deserves a harder look in three situations:
- You already have years of payments counting toward forgiveness under IBR or another older income-driven plan. The Massachusetts Attorney General warns that RAP payments don’t count toward forgiveness under those older plans, and you can’t switch back without losing that progress.
- Your loans are mostly subsidized and you’re early in repayment, so IBR’s interest help applies.
- You have no dependents and your income sits barely above a RAP band line. Run both numbers; the gap can close.
Parent PLUS loans, and consolidation loans that paid off a Parent PLUS loan, are not eligible for RAP, per the Illinois Attorney General’s RAP guide. If that’s you, call your servicer before the deadline to ask what’s open to you.
How to make the switch this week
- Find your deadline today. Open the servicer letter or log into your servicer account. Write the date on a sticky note on the fridge.
- Pull two numbers from your 2025 tax return: your AGI and the number of dependents you claimed.
- Run both plans. Use the RAP band and the IBR formula above. It takes about ten minutes with a phone calculator.
- Apply on StudentAid.gov. You’ll need your FSA ID, and you can authorize the IRS to send your income and dependent information directly, so there’s no paperwork to dig up (Edfinancial).
- Screenshot the confirmation and check your next statement. It should show the new plan and the new payment. If it shows Standard, call your servicer that day.
- Put your recertification date on the calendar. Both plans recalculate your payment every year. If you skip it, your payment can jump.
The catch
RAP’s $100 is $100 at today’s income. A raise moves you into a higher band, and a kid aging off your tax return takes away the $50 reduction. Plan for the payment to climb over time.
Thirty years is a long runway. RAP is built to keep the balance falling, not to make it disappear fast. If you get extra money down the road, paying ahead on the highest-rate loan still shortens the whole thing.
This doesn’t fix a loan in default. Defaulted loans aren’t eligible for IBR (Edfinancial IBR page), and getting out of default is a separate process with its own rules.
And the rules are still moving. Lawsuits over the SAVE shutdown are ongoing, and the Department of Education posts updates on StudentAid.gov. Pick your plan by your deadline anyway. Waiting on the courts means landing on a payment you never chose.
What to do this week
Find the deadline on your servicer notice and submit your RAP or IBR application on StudentAid.gov before it. Twenty minutes tonight could keep up to $204 a month in your budget instead of landing you on a fixed payment you didn’t pick.
Sources
- U.S. Department of Education, “U.S. Department of Education Announces Next Steps for Borrowers Enrolled in the Unlawful SAVE Plan”, 2026 (accessed November 22, 2026)
- Edfinancial Services (Federal Student Aid servicer), “Repayment Assistance Plan (RAP)” (accessed November 22, 2026)
- Edfinancial Services (Federal Student Aid servicer), “Income-Based Repayment (IBR)” (accessed November 22, 2026)
- U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, “Annual Update of the HHS Poverty Guidelines,” Federal Register Vol. 91, No. 10, January 15, 2026 (accessed November 22, 2026)
- Massachusetts Attorney General’s Office, “Repayment Assistance Plan (RAP)” (accessed November 22, 2026)
- Illinois Attorney General, “Repayment Assistance Plan” (accessed November 22, 2026)
RAP vs IBR: Pick Your Student Loan Plan Before SAVE Ends (Doing Nothing Could Cost Up to $204 More a Month) is a post from: Beating Broke, if you enjoy it, please visit us and subscribe to the Feed.