
The legal fight between Epic Games and Apple has been going on since 2020. While judgements and verdicts have been handed out, it doesn’t look like it’s ending anytime soon. Now, Epic is accusing Apple of withholding more than 122,000 documents in that case. It also wants daily fines imposed until Apple hands them over.
Epic says Apple is withholding documents about its proposed fees
For context, Apple was found in civil contempt in 2025 for charging up to 27% on purchases made through outside payment links. Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers is now deciding what commission, if any, Apple can charge on those purchases. Back in August, Apple proposed fees ranging from 5% to 15%.
Based on Epic’s court filing, both sides agreed on search terms for the files of Apple executives like Tim Cook and Phil Schiller. This is part of discovery, which in case you were wondering, is where each side has to hand over evidence to the other. However, Apple only produced 632 documents and held back the rest because it says they aren’t relevant. Epic says that’s “well over 99%” of the results.
Epic also says some pretty important stuff is missing. The company says there are no substantive emails about the rates Apple proposed. There are also no notes from meetings where those rates were decided. There are also no App Store profit and loss statements, or any internal analysis of how the fees would affect the business. Basically, Epic can’t challenge Apple’s fees if it can’t see how Apple decided on them.
Apple has been here before
This isn’t the first time Apple has been accused of sitting on documents. Back in 2024, a magistrate judge faulted Apple for stretching its privilege claims too far in this same case. In its filing, Epic argues that “Apple does introduce one tactical change from its prior campaign of delay.” So where Apple once leaned on privilege, Epic says it’s now leaning on relevance.
That being said, this is only Epic’s side, and Apple hasn’t publicly responded. Also to be fair, search terms like “injunction” and “contempt” can pull up plenty of documents that have nothing to do with how Apple set its fees.
As for what Epic wants, it’s asking the court to make Apple hand over every non-privileged document that matches the search terms by December 2. And like we said earlier, Epic wants a daily fine for each day Apple misses that deadline. However, it didn’t suggest an amount.
According to 9to5Mac, the dispute has since been sent to a magistrate judge, who will decide whether Epic is right about Apple withholding documents. In the meantime, the Supreme Court will hear Apple’s contempt appeal on January 11. So this battle is far from over.
The post Epic Wants Apple Fined Daily Over 122,000 Documents It Says Are Being Withheld appeared first on Android Headlines.