
It has been six years since Epic first filed its lawsuit against Apple. Unfortunately, it looks like this case isn’t going away anytime soon. Most recently, Epic accused Apple of withholding over 100,000 documents. The company also wanted Apple to pay a daily fine until all documents were handed over. To no one’s surprise, Apple disagrees with everything.
Apple says Epic’s search terms pulled in the wrong documents
9to5Mac reports that Apple has filed its response, asking the court to reject Epic’s motion. Apple argues that the search terms Epic proposed were “overbroad” and not tailored to the link-out fee proceedings. In case you were wondering, link-out fees are what Apple wants to charge when apps send users outside the App Store to make purchases.
For example, Apple says “commission*” picked up documents mentioning the NFL Commissioner. Meanwhile, “fee*” caught words like “feedback” and “feet.” Apple claims at least 95% of the documents hit on generic terms like these without any mention of “link-out.” Basically, Apple is claiming that Epic’s search terms were too broad, and they were essentially requesting for all documents that contained their search terms. Even if it might not have anything to do with the case.
According to Apple’s filing, “The law is clear: parties are only required to produce responsive documents, not every document returned by a search string.”
Apple offers a compromise
Apple also says handing everything over isn’t as simple as it sounds. This is because certain documents could expose executives’ private financial and medical records. It could also reveal unannounced products, passwords, and privileged communications. Plus, Apple says its vendors have already spent a staggering 20,485 hours on review. Epic’s demand would add over 17,000 more. Ultimately, Epic’s December 2 deadline is impossible to meet.
That being said, Apple is proposing an alternative. Apple suggests sending a random sample of the withheld documents to a Special Master. This is essentially an independent reviewer appointed by the court. Epic wouldn’t get to see them. Instead, a neutral party would check if Apple made the right calls. That way, any documents that might contain potentially sensitive information and aren’t relevant to the case won’t be exposed.
The court has yet to respond to Apple’s proposed alternative. As it stands, a magistrate judge will decide how this plays out. At the same time, Apple is still fighting its contempt ruling, with the Supreme Court set to hear its appeal in January. So it looks like this fight won’t be coming to an end anytime soon.
The post Apple Says Epic’s Document Demands Go Too Far appeared first on Android Headlines.