When it comes to AI’s potential impact on the economy, Marc Andreessen thinks extreme optimists and extreme pessimists have one thing in common: they are both wrong.
“Both the utopians and the doomers are going to be disappointed [by] the scope and magnitude of the real-world impact [of AI], and specifically the economic impact,” the prominent venture capitalist said Monday at the Federal Reserve’s AI conference in San Francisco.
Andreessen thinks both camps are overlooking that vast economic sectors—including health care, education, housing, law, and government—are blocked from rapid transformation by heavy regulation, limited competition, and other factors.
While this could limit AI-driven job losses in those sectors, it could also make their services increasingly expensive relative to other goods and services.
“[Health care] is already a fifth of U.S. GDP, and I don’t see why it doesn’t go to a fourth, a third and then half and then ultimately 80%,” Andreessen said.
The implications of this view depend on your values, he added.
“You might interpret this as good news, because it means the AI revolution is not going to, you know, destroy all the jobs or kill everybody,” he said. “You could also view this as very negative, which is [that] productivity … simply may not grow very much.”
Andreessen is the co-founder and general partner of Silicon Valley venture capital firm Andreessen Horowitz and co-leader of Fed chairman Kevin Warsh’s Productivity and Jobs Task Force.
Andreessen’s comments on Monday marked a change in tone, if not substance, from many of his previous remarks on AI.
In 2023, he famously argued that “AI will save the world” and that “productivity growth throughout the economy will accelerate dramatically”—leading to higher wages, lower prices and more jobs.
Andreessen has long conditioned his more bullish predictions about AI on the technology being allowed to proliferate freely throughout the economy. His comments on Monday suggest he is less confident about the prospects of that happening.
His argument is rooted in an economic phenomenon known as “Baumol’s cost disease,” which states that as technological advances make some goods and services cheaper to produce, goods and services that are less susceptible to productivity gains become relatively more expensive. This means that rapid technological progress in certain industries could leave Americans devoting an ever-larger share of their incomes to industries that have barely changed.
Fed chairman Warsh reportedly did not respond directly to the comments on Monday, describing AI as a “hinge point for the U.S. economy” and concluding that he is “cautiously optimistic.”
Before taking office, Warsh argued that AI could be a disinflationary force that increases productivity and justifies lower interest rates.