Tyler Robinson, the 22-year-old accused of killing conservative activist Charlie Kirk, may wear what he wishes during court appearances instead of jail garb but will remain restrained, a judge ruled Monday.
Robinson’s attorneys had argued that images of him shackled and in jail-issued clothing could prejudice future jurors, who would likely be exposed to the pictures given the widespread media attention and public interest in the case.
Judge Tony Graf agreed that the risk of prejudice is “significant,” and decided that the presumption of innocence Robinson is entitled to outweighs the “minimal inconvenience” of letting him dress in civilian attire.
“Mr. Robinson shall be dressed as one who is presumed innocent,” Graf said.
However, the judge also acknowledged that the charges against Robinson are “extraordinarily serious,” carrying potential penalties of life imprisonment or death.
Graf denied another defense motion to let the defendant appear in court without restraints, citing the need to keep all parties safe and the risk of disruption given the “emotional nature” of the case.
The judge directed the sheriff’s department to use the least restrictive restraints necessary to maintain safety, noting Robinson’s lack of criminal history and good behavior in jail. He also barred media from photographing or filming the restraints.
“This is a high profile case with strong public interest,” Graf said. “Restricting the recording of restraints strikes the proper balance between Mr. Robinson’s right to a fair proceeding and the public’s right to access and transparency.”
Utah state prosecutors charged Robinson with aggravated murder and six other counts after Kirk was struck in the neck with a single bullet and killed on Sept. 10, while giving a talk at Utah Valley University in Orem, Utah.
Investigators found bullet casings engraved with messaging that seemed to reference internet meme culture and anti-fascist efforts, and court filings referenced conversations Robinson allegedly had with his roommate, with whom he was apparently in a romantic relationship, about needing to recover a rifle he left wrapped in a towel in a bush. Â
The state intends to seek the death penalty. President Trump has called for a death sentence in the wake of Kirk’s killing, but Utah County Attorney General Jeff Gray said the decision was one he made “independently” based on the evidence and nature of the alleged crime.
Robinson is due back in court on Jan. 16 and Jan. 30, when he is expected to appear in person.
Â
