Mustafa Hussain for BI
Early in her Target career, Brooke Pratt wondered whether shoppers mistook her for an hourly worker as she helped restock shelves.
She was actually a department manager, earning substantially more than she had in her previous job, an entry-level desk position at a public-relations firm.
“I was thinking, this isn’t too bad,” Pratt told Business Insider. “I’m putting cereal on the shelf, and I’m making this kind of money. It’s pretty cool.”
Pratt, 34, is now a store director overseeing 350 team members and 10 department managers at one of Target’s largest locations, in Chaska, Minnesota.
Though a Target spokesperson said employees aren’t permitted to disclose their salary, the retailer recently advertised a role in Minnesota with the same title, offering $106,000 to $212,000 in annual base pay. The spokesperson said store directors are also eligible to receive an annual bonus and stock equity.
A premium for frontline managers
The six-figure salaries that some managers in retail, hospitality, and other service industries now command suggest that leadership sees them as on par with their white-collar managerial counterparts. The higher pay comes at a time, though, when some tech leaders are questioning whether they need so many middle layers in the first place.
Companies including Meta and Block have been cutting their managerial ranks in recent years, arguing that layers of bosses slow decision-making. Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong has said org chart layers impose a “coordination tax.“
Meanwhile, Walmart increased pay, annual stock grants, and potential bonuses last year for about 440 of its market managers, who oversee around a dozen stores. Top earners can now make as much as $620,000 in total compensation, up from about $569,000 previously.
Mustafa Hussain for BI
Salad chain Sweetgreen has said it plans to introduce a 2027 total compensation plan that could pay some managers of its top-performing locations more than $200,000 a year, part of a broader retention effort.
Similar pay ranges are on offer across other labor-intensive industries. Examples include $200,000 to $300,000 for a general manager at a car dealership in Illinois and about $117,000 to $195,000 for an Apple store leader in California.
Managing the unexpected
The cost of getting management wrong can be especially high in big-box retail, where managers are expected to run increasingly sophisticated operations across physical stores and online orders, said Scott Benedict, a retail consultant who worked in merchandising and e-commerce at Walmart and Sam’s Club.
“There’s a difference between finding a warm body and finding a leader of the caliber that you need to run what in some cases can be a $100 million or more business,” he said, referring to annual sales at a single big-box location.
The pressure can also be intense at a single restaurant.
On a recent Friday morning, two online orders for 50 salads apiece came in back-to-back at a Sweetgreen in Chicago, where Ramsess Salazar, 48, oversees 26 employees who serve several hundred customers a day. With fewer people on the floor than usual, the general manager said he split his team between the digital rush and in-store guests. He then told everyone to stay calm and keep pushing.
“I have stress as well, but I cannot show it to them,” Salazar said, adding that about 90 minutes later they were laughing about how many salads they had made.
Another time, a walk-in cooler broke down before lunch at a Sweetgreen in Boston, leaving Salazar with a 100-plus-salad corporate order to fill. He said he rerouted that day’s delivery to a nearby sister location’s cooler while a technician repaired the broken one.
Close to the frontline
The value that managers provide in consumer-facing businesses goes beyond solving crises. They often see problems and opportunities as they unfold — from a menu item that isn’t selling to a staffing or service issue — and have to respond before headquarters can.
Joe de la Torre, 25, is the general manager of Crush Yard’s Nashville location, a 34,000-square-foot entertainment venue offering pickleball, golf simulators, food and drinks, and other games and activities. He oversees six direct reports and 33 hourly employees, helping to run an operation that attracts between 500 and 2,000 visitors a day.
De la Torre said he keeps close tabs on the facility, walking around to ensure it meets the company’s standards for cleanliness, customer service, and the overall guest experience. He also sometimes helps resolve customer disputes, including disagreements among pickleball players. He then shares his observations with Crush Yard’s vice president of operations.
“You get to see all fronts of the business,” said de la Torre. He said he makes $84,000 a year in base salary, plus a bonus, which he estimated could bring his annual compensation to as much as $150,000.
Proximity to day-to-day operations can give service-industry managers local knowledge and influence over workers that headquarters can’t easily replicate, said Raffaella Sadun, a Harvard Business School professor. In many tech companies, by contrast, leaders believe digital tools and AI can move information without a human in the middle.
Mustafa Hussain for BI
That offers a lesson for white-collar managers, Sadun said: Stay close to clients and the work — and raise insights that headquarters can’t see on a dashboard.
Doing what it takes
The work of a frontline manager can be decidedly unglamorous. It often means spending nearly all day on one’s feet, pitching in when staffers call out, wearing a uniform, and working nights and weekends.
Pratt, the Target store director, wears tops in the retailer’s signature red while on the job, and carries a walkie-talkie throughout her shift to stay in constant contact with her staff. She’s also certified to use the store’s powered equipment, including a forklift, and fills in for junior colleagues when needed.
“It doesn’t matter really what level you are,” said Pratt, who added that she learned about leadership while serving as a cheerleading team captain in college. “We all work together as a team to get something done.”